What CROs & CAEs Aren’t Telling Boards About Risk & Assurance Coverage
Key Takeaways
- Mission Critical Objective Coverage: CROs and CAEs should explicitly identify which of their organization's most important strategic/value creation and value preservation objectives fall within their mandates and work plans, and which are excluded.
- Limitations of Traditional Risk Reporting: Risk registers, risk categories and audit plans do not necessarily establish whether mission critical objectives receive adequate risk assessment, performance reporting and independent assurance.
- Board Oversight and Transparency: CEOs and boards need a clear understanding of which mission critical objectives are covered, who is responsible for that coverage and where significant gaps exist.
- Formal Recognition of Coverage Gaps: CROs and CAEs should disclose gaps in risk and assurance coverage and seek documented confirmation that management and the board understand and accept existing arrangements or require changes.
- Accountability for Risk and Assurance: Clearly defined mandates and explicit disclosure of coverage limitations can help prevent misunderstandings about the responsibilities of risk management and internal audit when significant organizational failures occur.
Deep Dive
Chief risk officers and chief audit executives regularly tell CEOs and boards they are focused on their organization's top risks. I believe they should be required to answer a more fundamental question. Which of the organization's mission critical objectives are actually covered by their current mandates and work plans, and which are not?
I suspect many CROs and CAEs would have difficulty producing a complete answer. More concerning, I suspect many CEOs and boards do not realize how much they may be assuming about the coverage they receive.
ISO 31000 defines risk as the "effect of uncertainty on objectives." COSO's enterprise risk management framework similarly connects risk with strategy and performance. These are not obscure principles. They are foundational to how the profession says risk should be understood.
Yet much of the work performed by risk management and internal audit remains organized around risk registers, risk categories, business units, processes and traditional audit universes. These approaches can produce useful information. What they do not necessarily establish is whether the objectives most important to an organization's sustained success are receiving adequate risk assessment, performance reporting and assurance.
I call these mission critical objectives (MCOs). They include the strategic/value creation and value preservation objectives that matter most to an organization's future. In my view, this is where the real top risks reside.
If risk management and internal audit cannot explicitly identify which MCOs their work covers, CEOs and boards have no reliable basis for determining whether the information and assurance they receive address what matters most.
What Does the Board Believe Is Being Covered?
Consider a board that receives regular reports from its CRO identifying the organization's principal risks. The CAE presents an annual risk-based audit plan, reports on completed engagements and discusses significant control deficiencies.
The reporting may be thorough. The work may be performed competently and within the functions' approved mandates. But has anyone established whether those activities collectively provide adequate coverage of the organization's mission critical objectives?
A risk register may identify cybersecurity, regulatory compliance, operational resilience and third-party risk as significant exposures. An audit plan may prioritize information technology, financial reporting, procurement and selected operational processes.
These are legitimate areas of attention. They are not, however, a substitute for determining which MCOs are exposed to material uncertainty, what is being done to assess that uncertainty, and whether the controls and other measures relied upon to achieve those objectives are working.
An organization could have a substantial risk management function, an active internal audit department and extensive reporting to its board while still leaving important objectives with little structured risk assessment or independent assurance. The question is whether the CEO and board know that.
I believe there is a fundamental difference between a board approving a risk management or internal audit work plan and a board understanding which of its organization's most important objectives that plan does not cover. Too often, that receives insufficient attention.
Making Coverage and Its Limitations Explicit
I believe CROs and CAEs should take four steps to address this problem.
First, agree with the CEO and board on the organization's mission critical objectives.
The starting point should be the strategic/value creation and value preservation objectives most important to sustained success. It should not be an existing risk register or audit universe.
Determining which objectives are mission critical is ultimately a management and board responsibility. CROs and CAEs should contribute their expertise and challenge assumptions, but the objectives themselves must reflect what organizational leadership considers essential.
Second, explicitly disclose which MCOs are within and outside the current mandates and work plans of risk management and internal audit.
This should include both formally authorized responsibilities and the implicit expectations that may have developed between these functions, senior management and the board.
A risk management mandate or internal audit charter may describe responsibilities in broad terms. It does not necessarily establish which specific MCOs receive coverage.Nor should an approved annual work plan be taken as evidence that the CEO and board understand all the objectives excluded from it. Where coverage is partial, that limitation should also be disclosed.
Third, identify MCOs receiving little or no structured risk assessment, performance reporting or independent assurance from anyone.
This is important. An objective outside the CRO's or CAE's mandate is not necessarily unmanaged. Business leaders, specialist functions, external assurance providers and others may already be assessing risks, monitoring performance or evaluating controls. Some objectives may receive appropriate oversight without direct involvement from risk management or internal audit.
But CEOs and boards should know who is providing that coverage, what it consists of and whether significant gaps remain.
I am not suggesting that CROs should assume responsibility for every organizational objective or that CAEs should provide independent assurance over everything management does. The responsibilities of management, risk functions and internal audit are different, and those distinctions must be preserved. What I am suggesting is that the overall coverage of MCOs should be visible and understood.
Fourth, ask the CEO and board to confirm whether the existing coverage and identified gaps are acceptable, ideally in writing.
Not every objective requires the same level of risk assessment, reporting or assurance. Decisions about coverage should reflect the importance of the objective, the uncertainty surrounding its achievement and the information already available.
Some gaps may be acceptable. Others may require changes to risk management activities, management reporting or internal audit plans. Those judgments belong with the appropriate management and governance bodies. But they cannot be made intelligently if the gaps have not been identified. A documented discussion also helps establish what the CEO and board understood about the scope and limitations of the work being performed.
The Consequences of Unclear Expectations
CROs and CAEs should consider what happens when a mission critical objective fails and the CEO or board asks why the problem was not identified earlier. The objective may have been outside the function's authorized mandate. That may be a legitimate explanation.
But suppose the CRO had regularly reported on the organization's top risks, and the CAE had presented a risk-based assurance plan. Neither had explicitly disclosed that the failed objective was outside the scope of their work.
Would the CEO and board agree that the limitation had been understood and accepted? Or would they say they believed the organization's top risks were being covered? I believe this is a foreseeable source of serious misunderstanding.
The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency's enforcement proceedings involving former Wells Fargo risk and audit executives provide a reminder that senior control-function leaders can face significant consequences when regulators determine they have failed to fulfill their responsibilities.
Those proceedings arose from specific supervisory findings and should not be interpreted as establishing that CROs or CAEs have unlimited responsibility for every organizational objective. They do, however, reinforce the importance of understanding the duties attached to senior risk and audit positions.
The boundaries of a mandate are much easier to explain when they have been explicitly discussed and documented before a major failure.
CROs and CAEs who continue to describe their work as covering top risks without clarifying which MCOs are excluded should recognize the possibility that CEOs and boards understand those claims differently. That is a risk in its own right.
Boards Cannot Assess Coverage They Do Not Understand
I have long argued that risk management and internal audit need to be more closely connected to the objectives organizations are trying to achieve and preserve.
The profession has developed extensive methods for identifying, classifying, assessing and reporting risks. Internal audit has similarly developed sophisticated approaches to planning engagements and evaluating controls. These methods have value. But the existence of a mature process does not establish that the process is directed toward the objectives that matter most.
For CEOs and boards, the essential questions concern whether the organization's mission critical objectives are receiving adequate risk and performance information, who is responsible for providing it, what independent assurance is available and where significant gaps remain.
CROs and CAEs should be prepared to answer those questions within the responsibilities of their respective functions. They should also be prepared to identify important limitations in the coverage being provided. I believe boards should explicitly request this information rather than assume that reports on top risks or risk-based audit plans provide it.
An organization may decide, after proper consideration, that certain MCOs do not require additional risk assessment or independent assurance. That is different from leaving those objectives outside the scope of existing arrangements without the CEO and board understanding the implications.
The issue is not whether every mission critical objective must be covered by the CRO or CAE. It is whether the CEO and board know which objectives are covered, which are not, and who is responsible for addressing any significant gaps.
My question to CROs, CAEs and directors is whether your CEO and board regularly receive an explicit report identifying which mission critical objectives are in scope and out of scope for risk management and internal audit. If not, why not?
I would also welcome hearing from CROs and CAEs who already report regularly on risks linked to their organization's full range of mission critical objectives. I am interested in how they establish coverage, identify gaps and communicate that information to their CEOs and boards.
The GRC Report is your premier destination for the latest in governance, risk, and compliance news. As your reliable source for comprehensive coverage, we ensure you stay informed and ready to navigate the dynamic landscape of GRC. Beyond being a news source, the GRC Report represents a thriving community of professionals who, like you, are dedicated to GRC excellence. Explore our insightful articles and breaking news, and actively participate in the conversation to enhance your GRC journey.



