ACPR Study Links Biodiversity Footprints to Restoration Costs for Nature-Related Risk Analysis

Key Takeaways
- The ACPR's Risk Study and Analysis Directorate has published a methodological study that converts biodiversity footprints (expressed in MSA.km²) into estimated restoration costs.
- The study is analytical and non-binding, but it signals how French supervisors may approach nature-related transition risk.
- Compliance teams should note that it does not set new obligations, and should avoid reading its figures as a measure of economic value or as a pricing standard.
Deep Dive
The ACPR's Risk Study and Analysis Directorate has published a methodological study that converts biodiversity footprints (expressed in MSA.km²) into estimated restoration costs. The study is analytical and non-binding, but it signals how French supervisors may approach nature-related transition risk. Compliance teams should note that it does not set new obligations, and should avoid reading its figures as a measure of economic value or as a pricing standard.
The study builds a global curve of abatement and restoration costs, analogous to marginal abatement cost curves in climate economics. It extends preliminary work by CDC Biodiversité (2026) using only public data. It estimates that a four-point improvement in Mean Species Abundance (from the current baseline toward 100%, an intact ecosystem) would cost EUR 9 Trillion to EUR 11.9 Trillion over 35 years, or about 0.25% to 0.33% of global GDP per year. As an illustration, a footprint of 0.04 MSA.km² per EUR 1 Million invested equates to roughly EUR 68,000 to EUR 89,600 per EUR 1 Million, or about 0.2 points of annual asset return over 35 years. The footprint methodology uses Iceberg Data Lab data. It allocates impacts proportionally to insurers' asset holdings and to banks' AnaCredit exposures, and it includes scope 3 value chain impacts. The authors acknowledge that this can double count pressures, and describe the estimates as conservative. The study also notes that land use is the dominant pressure in the insurance portfolios examined. It proposes a preliminary link between biodiversity restoration and ecosystem services, using water stress as a case study.
The paper defines nature-related transition risk as the cost of curbing, avoiding, or restoring nature degradation. This complements the dependency-focused physical risk approach of the NGFS scenarios. Compliance and risk teams should:
- Review how biodiversity footprints are calculated and disclosed under LEC 29 and ESRS E4, and document the conventions used (allocation rules, scope 3 treatment, data coverage, vendor model choices).
- Make sure disclosures do not present footprint-to-cost conversions as valuations or as forecasts of actual costs.
- Track ACPR and NGFS work on nature stress testing and transition risk, as this paper may foreshadow supervisory expectations.
- Assess data lineage and quality, including entity mapping across financial identifiers, legal entities, and groups, plus the risk of double counting.
- Brief sustainability, risk, and portfolio management functions on the difference between impact metrics (biodiversity state) and dependency metrics (ecosystem services).
Near-term regulatory risk is low because the document is non-binding. The main exposures are model risk, disclosure and greenwashing risk if the illustrative cost figures are misused, and data quality risk, given heavy reliance on third-party estimates and methodological conventions. Over the medium term, institutions with land-use-intensive portfolios, such as agriculture, food, forestry, and infrastructure, may face greater scrutiny. Nature-related transition risk could also be integrated into scenario analysis and ICAAP/ORSA-type assessments.

