Find the Right GRC Solution

Search and compare GRC technology built for the problems you’re trying to solve

Dutch Financial Regulator Calls for Simpler Rules Without Weakening Market Protections

Dutch Financial Regulator Calls for Simpler Rules Without Weakening Market Protections

By
🔒
Cancel anytime
Full archive access
Custom alerts
Key Takeaways
  • Regulatory Simplification: The Netherlands Authority for the Financial Markets is supporting efforts to reduce unnecessary regulatory burdens, warning that excessive complexity can undermine the effectiveness of financial supervision.
  • European and National Requirements: The AFM intends to examine existing obligations and national implementation choices under European legislation while contributing to broader European simplification initiatives.
  • Supervisory Practices: Policy rules, guidance, regulatory interpretations, administrative processes, and interactions with supervised institutions are among the areas identified for potential improvement.
  • Industry Participation: Financial institutions are encouraged to propose changes, but the AFM will independently evaluate their implications for consumers and financial markets.
  • Consumer Protection: The regulator has emphasized that simplification must not weaken necessary safeguards and has not announced specific legislative amendments or implementation deadlines.
Deep Dive

The Netherlands Authority for the Financial Markets (AFM) has acknowledged that some of the rules governing the financial sector may be doing more work than they need to, imposing unnecessary obligations on firms without necessarily improving the protection of consumers or markets.

The Dutch regulator wants to address that problem through a closer examination of existing requirements, the way European legislation is implemented nationally, and its own supervisory practices. It is contributing to simplification efforts alongside the Netherlands Ministry of Finance and at the European level, where decisions about financial regulation can have consequences for institutions across multiple jurisdictions.

The initiative reflects a concern within the AFM about the cumulative effects of regulation. Individual requirements may be justified when introduced, particularly in response to financial crises or misconduct. Over time, however, additional rules can make the overall framework more complicated, while the original requirements remain largely intact.

The authority believes the familiar movement between stricter regulation following a crisis and subsequent demands for deregulation can leave financial markets with an unstable and less effective set of obligations. It is advocating a more consistent assessment of whether rules remain necessary, proportionate, and capable of achieving their intended objectives.

“Rules are not a standalone goal for us,” said Laura van Geest, chair of the AFM's Executive Board. “What matters is that they achieve their intended purpose: contributing to fair and resilient financial markets and consumer protection.”

Van Geest said unnecessarily complex or burdensome requirements should be improved, whether they are already in force or being considered as part of new legislation. She also stressed that strong safeguards must remain where they are needed.

The AFM's position places particular emphasis on the distinction between the burden imposed by regulation and the protection it delivers. A requirement may be demanding without being unnecessary. Equally, the existence of a rule offers little assurance of its value if its obligations are difficult to understand, impractical to implement, or disproportionate to the risks involved.

The regulator has identified several areas where it believes improvements may be possible. Existing rules and obligations are among the priorities, along with the national choices made when implementing European legislation. The AFM wants those decisions examined critically, particularly where they may introduce complexity beyond what is necessary to achieve the underlying regulatory objectives.

It is also looking at the supervisory requirements and interpretations that financial institutions encounter in their dealings with the authority. Policy rules, guidance, and regulatory interpretations may be streamlined, while administrative processes and communication between the AFM and supervised firms could be improved.

These are areas where the experience of complying with regulation can be shaped by supervisory practice as well as legislation. Clearer guidance and more workable processes could reduce unnecessary effort without requiring changes to the underlying legal obligations.

At the European level, the AFM intends to contribute to broader discussions about simplifying financial regulation. Its approach will be guided by five principles: protection of public interests, proportionality, effectiveness, clarity, and feasibility. The authority is also asking the financial sector to participate.

Market participants are encouraged to identify obligations and supervisory practices they believe could be improved. The AFM says it is open to suggestions and wants institutions to contribute to discussions about how regulation and supervision can work more effectively.

That invitation does not amount to a commitment to accept the industry's proposals. The regulator has emphasized that it will make independent assessments, with the effects on consumers and financial markets taking priority.

There are limits to what simplification can reasonably accomplish. The AFM acknowledges that some requirements cannot or should not be changed, and that revisions made without sufficient consideration could introduce new risks or make supervision more difficult. It has also cautioned that meaningful changes take time.

For now, the authority has not announced specific legislative amendments, identified individual requirements for repeal, or established a timetable for reducing regulatory obligations. Its statement sets out the principles it intends to apply and the areas in which it will pursue improvements. The AFM says it will continue participating in national and European initiatives and communicate about its efforts at a high level.

The practical results will depend partly on decisions beyond the regulator's direct control, particularly where changes to European legislation or national implementation are concerned. Improvements to its own guidance and supervisory processes may offer a more immediate opportunity, although the AFM has not committed to particular measures.

What the authority has established is a willingness to question whether the requirements imposed on financial institutions are serving their intended purpose. That examination includes the work of supervisors themselves, whose interpretations and procedures can add to the demands of compliance.

The AFM has made clear that it does not regard fewer rules as an achievement in itself. The measure of success will be whether financial regulation becomes more understandable and workable while continuing to protect the people and markets it was established to serve.

The GRC Report is your premier destination for the latest in governance, risk, and compliance news. As your reliable source for comprehensive coverage, we ensure you stay informed and ready to navigate the dynamic landscape of GRC. Beyond being a news source, the GRC Report represents a thriving community of professionals who, like you, are dedicated to GRC excellence. Explore our insightful articles and breaking news, and actively participate in the conversation to enhance your GRC journey

Oops! Something went wrong