Find the Right GRC Solution

Search and compare GRC technology built for the problems you’re trying to solve

European Commission Finds Temu's Product Safety Controls Fall Short Under Digital Services Act

European Commission Finds Temu's Product Safety Controls Fall Short Under Digital Services Act

By
Key Takeaways
  • Preliminary DSA Breach: The European Commission preliminarily found that Temu failed to implement reasonable, proportionate and effective measures to mitigate the risk of illegal products being offered on its marketplace, in violation of Article 35 of the Digital Services Act.
  • Insufficient Product Safety Checks: Temu requires testing reports for only a small proportion of products and frequently fails to verify them. Investigators also found that high-risk categories, including toys, electronics and cosmetics, are not prioritized during physical inspections.
  • Weak Content Moderation: The Commission found that Temu's moderation arrangements focus too heavily on listing information and compliance with platform rules rather than product safety, while human moderator staffing has not kept pace with the growth in listings.
  • Ineffective Trader Sanctions: Temu's enforcement measures generally target individual stores rather than the traders operating them, allowing sellers with multiple storefronts to continue operating after a store closure. Serious violations can also accumulate before suspensions occur.
  • Further Penalties Possible: Temu can respond to the preliminary findings before a final decision. If the Commission confirms a breach, the company could face a fine of up to 6% of its total worldwide annual turnover and orders to implement corrective measures.
Deep Dive

A trader whose store is closed on Temu can continue selling through another store on the platform. According to the European Commission, that is one of several weaknesses in the online marketplace's enforcement system, which regulators preliminarily found to be in breach of the European Union's Digital Services Act.

The Commission's findings describe shortcomings in nearly every stage of Temu's efforts to prevent illegal products from being offered for sale. Product testing reports are required for only a small share of goods, and even those reports frequently go unchecked. Products the company itself considers high risk do not receive priority during physical inspections. Traders can commit numerous serious violations before their stores are suspended.

The preliminary findings concern Article 35 of the Digital Services Act (DSA), which requires platforms to implement reasonable, proportionate and effective measures to mitigate identified systemic risks. The Commission concluded that Temu's arrangements for addressing the risk of illegal products being offered on its marketplace do not meet that obligation.

The decision adds to a difficult year for the company in Brussels. In May, the Commission fined Temu €200 million for failing to conduct an appropriate risk assessment under the DSA. Regulators approved the company's action plan to remedy that breach in October. The latest proceedings concern a separate requirement, examining whether the measures Temu has put in place are sufficient to address the risks associated with illegal products.

Investigators found that Temu's product controls place too little emphasis on establishing whether goods comply with European safety requirements. Sellers are required to provide testing reports for only a very small proportion of products, according to the Commission. Even when those reports are required, Temu often does not verify them.

The company identifies toys, electronics and cosmetics among its high-risk product categories, but investigators found that these classifications do not determine which goods receive priority during physical inspections. Temu also frequently failed to follow up on the results of spot checks or expand inspections as the number of listings increased. The Commission identified similar deficiencies in the platform's content moderation system.

Rather than concentrating sufficiently on product safety, Temu's moderation procedures appear to focus primarily on the information accompanying listings and whether sellers comply with the company's terms and conditions. Its system for comparing listings against products previously identified as noncompliant also gives insufficient attention to the risk of unsafe goods.

The number of human moderators has not grown in proportion to the increase in listings, according to the findings. The Commission did not disclose staffing figures in its announcement, but included the disparity among the shortcomings in Temu's moderation arrangements.

The weaknesses extend to the penalties imposed on traders who violate the platform's rules. Temu's sanctions generally apply to individual stores rather than the traders responsible for operating them. Because one trader can maintain several stores, the closure of one does not necessarily prevent that trader from continuing to sell through others.

Investigators also found evidence that traders could commit a large number of serious infringements, including selling products that failed safety checks, before Temu suspended any of their stores. The Commission described the sanction system as fragmented, insufficiently targeted and lacking an effective deterrent.

For regulators, the concern is not simply whether Temu can identify an unsafe product or remove a particular listing. The findings raise questions about whether its controls can prevent repeated violations, particularly when the same trader operates multiple storefronts.

The November assessment forms part of formal proceedings opened in October 2024, when the Commission began investigating Temu's compliance with several provisions of the DSA. Those proceedings cover the sale of illegal products, potentially addictive design features, purchase recommendation systems and access to platform data for researchers.

The latest preliminary findings address only the company's obligation to implement concrete measures to mitigate the risk of illegal products under Article 35. Temu now has the opportunity to examine the Commission's investigation file and submit a written response. The European Board for Digital Services will also be consulted before regulators reach a final decision.

If the Commission ultimately confirms its preliminary assessment, it may adopt a formal noncompliance decision and impose a proportionate fine of up to 6% of the provider's total worldwide annual turnover. It may also order the company to take measures to address the breach. No additional fine has been imposed in connection with the November findings.

"Shopping online should not mean risking the purchase of illegal and unsafe products," said Henna Virkkunen, the Commission's executive vice president for tech sovereignty, security and democracy.

The earlier €200 million penalty concerned Temu's failure to assess risks appropriately. The current proceedings examine the measures intended to mitigate them. That leaves the Commission considering a more immediate question about how the marketplace operates. Temu has procedures for checking products, moderating listings and penalizing sellers. Investigators have now set out why they believe those procedures are insufficient, including instances in which product reports went unchecked, inspection results were not followed up and traders could continue operating despite repeated infringements.

 The GRC Report is your premier destination for the latest in governance, risk, and compliance news. As your reliable source for comprehensive coverage, we ensure you stay informed and ready to navigate the dynamic landscape of GRC. Beyond being a news source, the GRC Report represents a thriving community of professionals who, like you, are dedicated to GRC excellence. Explore our insightful articles and breaking news, and actively participate in the conversation to enhance your GRC journey.

Oops! Something went wrong