Find the Right GRC Solution

Search and compare GRC technology built for the problems you’re trying to solve

FCA Final Report on Pure Protection Market Study Targets Protection Gap Without New Rules

FCA Final Report on Pure Protection Market Study Targets Protection Gap Without New Rules

By
Regulatory data powered by Corlytics
The FCA concluded its pure protection distribution market study, finding that competition generally works well but that 58% of people hold no protection produc…
🔒
Cancel anytime
Full archive access
Custom alerts
Key Takeaways
  • The FCA concluded its pure protection distribution market study, finding that competition generally works well but that 58% of people hold no protection products.
  • Rather than introducing new rules, the FCA will rely on industry-led and FCA-led initiatives, existing frameworks such as the Consumer Duty and PROD 4, and continued supervisory and enforcement action.
  • Compliance teams should prepare for scrutiny of fair value evidence and remuneration arrangements, and decide how to engage with the implementation work.
Deep Dive

The FCA concluded its pure protection distribution market study, finding that competition generally works well but that 58% of people hold no protection products. Rather than introducing new rules, the FCA will rely on industry-led and FCA-led initiatives, existing frameworks such as the Consumer Duty and PROD 4, and continued supervisory and enforcement action. Compliance teams should prepare for scrutiny of fair value evidence and remuneration arrangements, and decide how to engage with the implementation work.

Demand-side measures include protection prompts at life events (MaPS MoneyHelper and the Digital Property Market Steering Group have already agreed to add them), an Association of Mortgage Intermediaries initiative on adviser engagement, and a sustained, market-wide consumer awareness program led by the Protection Distributors Group (PDG). The FCA expects firms and industry bodies to provide funding and participate in the PDG governance structure. Supply-side measures include a possible TechSprint, work to reduce delays in obtaining medical records, support for improving access for people with variable incomes, and a myth-busting webinar on regulatory expectations. The FCA also expects firms to consider adding information on trusts and nominated beneficiaries to consumer-facing materials. Initiatives must comply with competition law and have clear success measures.

On price and quality, the FCA identified a few smaller, non-systemic issues. These include intermediaries possibly being incentivized to switch customers unnecessarily and industry requests for clarity on adjusting premiums for commission. It reminded firms of their obligations under the Consumer Duty and PROD 4. Its review of fair value assessments found room for firms to strengthen the evidence behind target market value assessments and the effect of remuneration and distribution arrangements on outcomes. The FCA states it will use supervisory or enforcement action where firms fall short, rather than broad market-wide measures.

The FCA engagement with industry begins in October 2026, and work begins by the end of 2026. Expressions of interest for the TechSprint are due by 13 November 2026, with confirmation by the end of 2026 and the event expected in Q3 2027. The FCA expects meaningful progress within 12 to 18 months and will publish a short progress update by the end of 2027. It does not currently consider further regulation necessary but will reconsider if outcomes do not improve.

Recommended actions:

(1) Review fair value assessments, target market evidence, and remuneration and distribution arrangements against the report's examples and areas for improvement.

(2) Examine incentive structures and switching practices for potential unnecessary switching.

(3) Decide whether to take part in the PDG and AMI initiatives and the TechSprint, and assess funding and competition law implications.

(4) Review customer journeys, underwriting, communications and prompts for friction and clarity, including for vulnerable and non-standard-income customers.

(5) Consider collecting data on where consumers were first prompted.

(6) Document Consumer Duty outcome monitoring, since the lack of new rules does not lower supervisory expectations.

Risk impact: Regulatory risk is moderate. Firms that cannot evidence fair value or that retain conflicted incentives face the greatest exposure to supervisory or enforcement action. Conduct risk is highest for firms serving underserved groups. Participation in collaborative industry initiatives also carries competition law risk that needs legal oversight.

Source: Financial Conduct Authority

Oops! Something went wrong