FCA Pure Protection Market Study Feedback Statement Confirms Good Outcomes and Light-Touch Remedies

Key Takeaways
- The FCA's Annex 1 summarizes roughly 50 responses to its Interim Report on pure protection distribution.
- It confirms that the market generally delivers good consumer outcomes, that premiums are stable, and that insurer margins are modest.
- The FCA is favoring a proportionate, non-interventionist package built around prompts and nudges, and it is not extending targeted support to protection at this stage.
- Compliance teams should still prepare for continued scrutiny of economic abuse risks, value-added services, income protection value, and commission-driven switching.
Deep Dive
The FCA's Annex 1 summarizes roughly 50 responses to its Interim Report on pure protection distribution. It confirms that the market generally delivers good consumer outcomes, that premiums are stable, and that insurer margins are modest. The FCA is favoring a proportionate, non-interventionist package built around prompts and nudges, and it is not extending targeted support to protection at this stage. Compliance teams should still prepare for continued scrutiny of economic abuse risks, value-added services, income protection value, and commission-driven switching.
The statement restates several existing expectations that firms should treat as live supervisory priorities. Under the Consumer Duty, the Vulnerable Customers guidance and PROD 4, firms must understand customer needs and avoid foreseeable harm. That includes the risk that joint policies are used as tools of domestic financial abuse. The FCA warns advisers against assuming joint policies must be recommended simply because they are cheaper. For value-added services such as digital GP access and mental health support, ICOBS 2.2.2 requires communications to be clear, fair and not misleading. Firms must make clear where services are non-contractual, avoid giving them undue prominence, and include their value in fair value assessments. Concerns about service standards can be referred to the Supervision Hub.
On claims experience, the FCA supports wider use of trusts, wills, powers of attorney and contractual beneficiary nomination, and it noted the "beneficiary gap" in non-advised channels. Respondents also supported publishing time-to-pay data. For income protection, the FCA will refresh its value assessment using 2025 premium and cost data. Its figures were a 40% claims ratio, a 12% margin and 86% claims acceptance. Respondents attributed these to multiple claims, concentrated reinsurance, higher capital requirements and rehabilitation services, and to non-disclosure leading to declined claims. No specific deadlines are stated. The Final Report is the next milestone, and a March 2026 workshop already informed the protection gap work.
Recommended actions:
- Review sales and advice processes for joint versus single policy recommendations, and document the rationale beyond price.
- Update the vulnerability and economic abuse controls, referencing the ABI and CII good practice guides.
- Test promotions and journeys for value-added services against ICOBS 2.2.2, and reflect those services in fair value assessments.
- Assess how consistently trusts, wills and beneficiary nominations are offered, and consider time-to-pay MI.
- Reduce friction in underwriting and medical evidence, especially for customers with pre-existing conditions.
- Income protection providers should prepare data and evidence of value, including capital, reinsurance and rehabilitation context.
- Distributors should review commission, switching and panel structures ahead of the Final Report.
Source: Financial Conduct Authority

