FinCEN Slaps Canaccord Genuity With Record $80 Million Penalty Over AML Failures

Key Takeaways

• Record BSA Enforcement: FinCEN imposed an $80 million civil money penalty on Canaccord Genuity, the largest penalty ever assessed against a broker-dealer for Bank Secrecy Act violations.
• Hundreds of Missed Reports: Regulators say the firm failed to file at least 160 suspicious activity reports, despite thousands of transactions tied to potentially suspicious trading in over-the-counter securities.
• Weak AML Program: FinCEN found Canaccord’s anti-money laundering program was under-resourced and relied on insufficiently trained staff and poorly designed monitoring processes.
• High-Risk Customers Passed Through Controls: Deficiencies in customer due diligence allowed accounts linked to individuals tied to securities fraud schemes and other illicit actors.
• Regulatory Warnings Went Unaddressed: Examinations had previously identified AML weaknesses, but regulators say meaningful remediation did not occur for years.

Deep Dive

The U.S. Treasury Department’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network has issued an $80 million civil money penalty against Canaccord Genuity, accusing the broker-dealer of willfully violating the Bank Secrecy Act (BSA) through systemic anti-money laundering failures tied to securities fraud activity.

The enforcement action marks the largest penalty FinCEN has ever imposed on a broker-dealer for BSA violations, a milestone that signals the agency’s growing focus on how securities markets can be exploited for financial crime.

In announcing the penalty, FinCEN Director Andrea Gacki described the case as a warning to broker-dealers that treat anti-money laundering obligations as a secondary function rather than a core safeguard for the financial system.

“Today’s action should be a wake-up call to broker-dealers that willfully fail to comply with their obligations to safeguard the financial system from illicit actors,” Gacki said. “FinCEN is committed to holding accountable financial institutions of all types, including institutions accessing our world-class capital markets, that willfully ignore their role in preventing and reporting illicit actors who seek to take advantage of hardworking Americans.”

Fraud Signals That Went Unreported

According to FinCEN, Canaccord’s compliance failures meant suspicious trading activity moved through the firm without being reported to authorities.

Regulators said the firm failed to file at least 160 suspicious activity reports, despite trading activity involving dozens of over-the-counter securities that generated thousands of transactions exhibiting red flags.

Suspicious activity reports play a central role in financial crime investigations, providing law enforcement with early intelligence about potential fraud or money laundering. FinCEN said the firm’s reporting failures deprived investigators of timely financial information connected to possible securities fraud schemes that caused significant harm to investors.

As part of the resolution, Canaccord admitted it willfully violated the Bank Secrecy Act by failing to establish and maintain an effective anti-money laundering program, failing to conduct required due diligence on certain correspondent accounts for foreign financial institutions, and failing to file suspicious activity reports.

Weak Customer Due Diligence

FinCEN also cited deficiencies in how the firm vetted and monitored its customers.

The agency said weaknesses in Canaccord’s risk-based customer due diligence allowed high-risk clients with reported ties to illicit actors to gain access to the U.S. financial system without appropriate oversight.

Among the examples cited were:

• A customer later fined and barred by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission from the penny stock industry for involvement in multiple microcap fraud schemes
• A customer reportedly involved in helping Russian oligarchs move money out of Russia
• A customer publicly linked to investigations involving a Venezuelan individual sanctioned by the Treasury Department’s Office of Foreign Assets Control

FinCEN said the firm’s compliance controls failed to identify or appropriately manage the risks associated with those accounts.

An AML Program Outmatched by the Business

The case also highlights operational shortcomings inside the firm’s compliance program.

FinCEN said Canaccord’s anti-money laundering framework was significantly under-resourced relative to the risks posed by its business model, particularly its role as a market maker in certain securities where fraud risks can be elevated.

The firm’s transaction monitoring system relied on a limited number of inexperienced staff who were poorly trained and overwhelmed by the volume of transactions they were expected to review. Surveillance reports used to flag suspicious trading activity were also described by regulators as poorly designed.

Taken together, those weaknesses made it difficult for the firm to identify suspicious transactions that flowed through its trading operations.

Problems Regulators Had Already Flagged

The enforcement action also traces the issue back several years.

According to FinCEN, examinations conducted by the firm’s regulator repeatedly identified deficiencies in Canaccord’s AML program, including gaps in its monitoring of suspicious transactions.

While the firm committed in writing to address those issues, regulators said meaningful remediation did not occur for years. In some cases, corrective measures were not implemented until FinCEN’s investigation was already underway.

Alongside the penalty, FinCEN used the case to reiterate expectations for broker-dealers operating under the Bank Secrecy Act.

The agency stressed that AML programs must be risk-based and scaled to the complexity and transaction volume of the firm’s activities, particularly where securities fraud risks are present. Broker-dealers are also expected to conduct meaningful customer due diligence and maintain internal controls capable of detecting suspicious activity such as penny stock scams and other market manipulation schemes.

The GRC Report is your premier destination for the latest in governance, risk, and compliance news. As your reliable source for comprehensive coverage, we ensure you stay informed and ready to navigate the dynamic landscape of GRC. Beyond being a news source, the GRC Report represents a thriving community of professionals who, like you, are dedicated to GRC excellence. Explore our insightful articles and breaking news, and actively participate in the conversation to enhance your GRC journey.