Find the Right GRC Solution

Search and compare GRC technology built for the problems you’re trying to solve

France’s CNIL Fines Company €5 Million for Password Security & Data Retention Failures

France’s CNIL Fines Company €5 Million for Password Security & Data Retention Failures

By
🔒
Cancel anytime
Full archive access
Custom alerts
Key Takeaways
  • €5 Million Penalty: France's CNIL fined an unnamed company for violations of GDPR requirements governing personal data security and storage limitation.
  • Password Security Failures: Customer passwords were stored in plain text, while employees shared credentials used to access customer databases, undermining individual accountability.
  • Excessive Data Retention: The company kept customer contact-form information for more than 10 years and retained connection records beyond its established one-year limit.
  • Corrective Action Taken: During enforcement proceedings, the company strengthened security measures, deleted unnecessary historical records and implemented monthly data purges.
  • Regulatory Findings Published: The CNIL withheld the company's identity but published its findings to reinforce organizations' obligations to protect personal information.
Deep Dive

France's data protection authority has fined an unnamed company €5 million after finding that it stored customer passwords in plain text, allowed employees to share database access credentials and retained certain personal information for more than a decade.

The Commission Nationale de l'Informatique et des Libertés (CNIL) announced the penalty on November 18, following an investigation into the company's handling of customer passwords and answers to security questions used to access accounts on its website. The inspection uncovered deficiencies in the company's security arrangements and its practices for retaining customer information.

The CNIL's restricted panel, which is responsible for imposing sanctions, found that the company had violated two provisions of the European Union's General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). The first concerned its obligation to protect personal data under Article 32. The second involved the storage limitation requirements of Article 5(1)(e), which prohibit organizations from retaining identifiable personal information longer than necessary.

The regulator did not identify the company, although it elected to publish the decision. In determining the €5 million penalty, the panel considered the seriousness of the violations, the number of individuals concerned and the company's financial capacity.

Among the findings was a failure to implement basic safeguards for customer account passwords. At the time of the inspections, and until the beginning of enforcement proceedings, the company stored those passwords in plain text rather than using appropriate protective measures.

The practice left passwords readable in the company's systems, exposing customer accounts to unnecessary risk if that information were accessed without authorization.

Investigators also found that employees shared usernames and passwords used to access customer databases and the tool through which those databases were managed. Such arrangements made it difficult to establish which employee had accessed particular information or performed a given action.

The CNIL emphasized that individual accounts are necessary for effective traceability within information systems, particularly when an organization must investigate a security incident or personal data breach. Without individually attributable access records, reconstructing activity can become considerably more difficult.

The restricted panel determined that the company's arrangements failed to satisfy the security requirements of Article 32.

It acknowledged that the company had introduced several measures to strengthen its security during the proceedings. Those changes addressed deficiencies identified by the regulator but did not alter its finding that the earlier practices had violated the GDPR.

Retention Rules Ignored

The inspection also revealed that the company had retained personal information submitted through its customer contact form for more than 10 years. The CNIL considered that period excessive once the requests associated with the information had been processed. Keeping the records for years afterward could no longer be justified by the purpose for which they had originally been collected.

A separate finding concerned customer connection data. The company had established a one-year retention period for those records but continued to keep them beyond that deadline, despite their no longer being necessary for the purposes pursued.

The two findings reflected different shortcomings in the company's handling of personal information. In the first, data had been kept for an excessive period after its usefulness had ended. In the second, the company had failed to observe a retention limit already established in its own policy.

Both constituted violations of Article 5(1)(e) of the GDPR.

The CNIL reiterated that organizations must delete or anonymize personal information when its retention is no longer necessary, or archive it where continued storage is required by law.

During the proceedings, the company deleted historical records that no longer served a necessary purpose and implemented a monthly process for purging customer data. The restricted panel acknowledged these corrective measures alongside the improvements to the company's security controls.

The decision to publish the sanction without identifying the company was deliberate. The CNIL said the findings warranted public attention because securing information accessible through passwords is a fundamental principle of data protection. The panel considered publication useful for reminding organizations of their obligations without finding it necessary to disclose the company's name.

The authority did not report a confirmed data breach or establish that customer passwords had been compromised. Its findings concerned the company's failure to maintain adequate safeguards and its continued retention of information beyond the periods justified by its purposes.

 The GRC Report is your premier destination for the latest in governance, risk, and compliance news. As your reliable source for comprehensive coverage, we ensure you stay informed and ready to navigate the dynamic landscape of GRC. Beyond being a news source, the GRC Report represents a thriving community of professionals who, like you, are dedicated to GRC excellence. Explore our insightful articles and breaking news, and actively participate in the conversation to enhance your GRC journey.

Oops! Something went wrong