Germany Fines Landfill Materials Suppliers €5.5 Million Over Cartel Dating Back to 2007

Key Takeaways
- €5.5 Million in Cartel Fines: Germany’s Bundeskartellamt imposed fines totaling approximately €5.5 million on G quadrat, Naue Sealing, and KAT Kunststoff-Abdichtungs-Systeme for illegal agreements involving landfill sealing contracts.
- More Than 16 Years of Collusion: Since at least 2007, Naue Sealing, G quadrat, and Solmax Geosynthetics had allocated contracts according to agreed market shares of approximately 35%, 25%, and 40%, respectively.
- Coordinated Bids and Prices: The companies used cover bids, agreed target and minimum prices, and maintained project lists to monitor compliance with their quotas.
- Leniency Led to Investigation: Solmax disclosed the cartel and avoided sanctions under the authority’s leniency program. Naue Sealing and G quadrat subsequently cooperated following a September 2023 raid.
- Settlements Are Final: All three fined companies agreed to settlements. The Bundeskartellamt said it would publish a case summary under Section 53(5) of the German Competition Act.
Deep Dive
Germany’s competition authority has fined three suppliers of landfill sealing materials approximately €5.5 million for participating in a cartel that operated for more than 16 years, with companies agreeing in advance who would receive contracts and how much business each should secure. The Federal Cartel Office (Bundeskartellamt) announced the penalties on November 16 against G quadrat, Naue Sealing & Co. KG, and KAT Kunststoff-Abdichtungs-Systeme. A fourth company, Solmax Geosynthetics, avoided sanctions after disclosing the arrangement under the authority’s leniency program.
The cartel dated back to at least 2007. Representatives of Naue Sealing, G quadrat, and Solmax met several times a year to divide upcoming contracts for sealing landfill sites across Germany. They agreed that Solmax would receive approximately 40% of the total contract volume, Naue Sealing 35%, and G quadrat 25%.
Those quotas were closely monitored. The companies maintained project lists to track contract allocations and ensure that each supplier received its agreed share. When a contract was assigned to one company, that supplier established prices for key products and services or determined the overall tender price. The others then submitted cover bids based on those figures, giving the contracting authority competing offers without genuine competition between the participants. The companies also agreed on target prices and minimum prices when necessary to keep market prices at levels acceptable to them.
“For many years, Naue Sealing, G quadrat and Solmax Geosynthetics had been eliminating competition between themselves in the awarding of contracts for the sealing of landfill sites,” said Andreas Mundt, president of the Bundeskartellamt.
Mundt described the arrangement as a quota cartel, in which competitors cooperate to secure predetermined portions of the market rather than compete independently for contracts. Such agreements, he said, can lead to excessive prices and significant financial damage for contracting authorities.
The conduct took place in a highly concentrated market. Geosynthetics are manufactured materials used in civil engineering, including synthetic liners designed to prevent pollutants from landfill sites from entering surrounding soil and groundwater. In Germany, liners used for landfill sealing must be approved by the Federal Institute for Materials Research and Testing (BAM).
According to the Bundeskartellamt, the four companies involved in the proceedings are the only suppliers of approved synthetic liners for installation at German landfill sites.
That limited the available sources of approved materials. The cartel further restricted competition by coordinating which supplier would receive particular contracts and the prices submitted by the other participants.
KAT’s involvement was confined to a project in 2023. Unlike the other three suppliers, the company had not attended the regular cartel meetings and only occasionally undertook landfill construction contracts. The other participants nevertheless allocated a project to KAT, which then set the prices that Naue Sealing, G quadrat, and Solmax would use in their cover bids.
The arrangement continued until September 12, 2023, when Bundeskartellamt investigators raided a conference hotel and interrupted a cartel meeting. Representatives had gathered to allocate contracts expected in the following weeks and update the project lists used to monitor compliance with their quotas.
The investigation had been initiated after Solmax submitted a leniency application to the competition authority. Under the Bundeskartellamt’s leniency program, proceedings against the company were discontinued.
Naue Sealing and G quadrat subsequently cooperated with investigators following the raid. In calculating the fines, the authority considered the size of the affected market, the size of the companies involved, and the extent and quality of their cooperation.
The Bundeskartellamt did not disclose the individual fines imposed on the three companies or provide an estimate of the financial damage caused by the cartel in its announcement.
All three fined companies agreed to settlements, and the decisions are final. The authority said it would publish a case summary under Section 53(5) of the German Competition Act.
The findings describe a procurement market in which competitors continued submitting separate bids while privately coordinating the outcome. For the contracts covered by the arrangement, the companies had already settled the allocation of work before the contracting authorities could assess their offers. The agreed quotas, maintained and monitored over many years, determined how that business was to be shared.
The GRC Report is your premier destination for the latest in governance, risk, and compliance news. As your reliable source for comprehensive coverage, we ensure you stay informed and ready to navigate the dynamic landscape of GRC. Beyond being a news source, the GRC Report represents a thriving community of professionals who, like you, are dedicated to GRC excellence. Explore our insightful articles and breaking news, and actively participate in the conversation to enhance your GRC journey.


