Find the Right GRC Solution

Search and compare GRC technology built for the problems you’re trying to solve

Italy Fines Meta €805 Million Over Facebook Access to Android Users’ Photo Libraries

Italy Fines Meta €805 Million Over Facebook Access to Android Users’ Photo Libraries

By
Key Takeaways
  • €805 Million Fine Imposed: Italy's privacy regulator fined Meta Platforms Ireland Limited for accessing Android users' photographs, videos and associated metadata without obtaining specific, informed consent.
  • Approximately 20 Million Users Affected: The investigation found that Facebook relied on a general permission covering multiple functions and had enabled camera roll suggestions by default.
  • Consent Changes Required Within 60 Days: Meta must introduce a separate consent request and disable the feature by default, including for users who previously authorized access.
  • Jurisdictional Objection Rejected: The Garante determined that the ePrivacy provisions involved do not provide for the GDPR's one-stop-shop mechanism.
  • AI Training Outside Investigation's Scope: The proceedings did not examine whether photographs were used for AI training. The authority may separately investigate Meta's cloud-based camera roll processing feature.
Deep Dive

A feature that suggests photographs from a user's phone while browsing Facebook has cost Meta €805 million after Italy's privacy regulator found that the company accessed Android users' photo libraries without obtaining specific consent.

The Italian Data Protection Authority, known as the Garante, announced the penalty against Meta Platforms Ireland Limited. Its investigation found that Facebook relied on a general permission to access photographs, videos and associated metadata stored on users' phones, without adequately explaining that the permission also covered a feature offering suggestions from their camera rolls.

The findings concern approximately 20 million Android users in Italy. Meta has been given 60 days to change how the feature obtains consent and ensure that it remains disabled by default, including for users who previously granted Facebook permission to access their photo libraries.

The feature, called "Get camera roll suggestions when you're browsing Facebook," has been available since 2023. It offers users photographs and videos from their phones as possible material for Facebook posts. According to the Garante, the problem lay in how the application obtained permission to access that material.

The investigation began in July 2025 following a report from the Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti, a consumer protection organization based in Bolzano. The authority subsequently conducted a technical examination of Facebook's permission settings and the operation of the feature.

Investigators found that Facebook requested a single authorization to access the camera roll, with that permission applying across the application to multiple functions serving different purposes. Users were presented with a general notice about enabling additional features, but the notice did not make clear that they were also authorizing Facebook to suggest content from their photo libraries. The suggestions feature was also enabled by default.

When granted in full, the permission could allow Facebook to read the entire photographic archive stored on an Android device, generally on a continuing basis. The regulator said neither users nor the authority could verify precisely which information the application was using.

The distinction is important to the findings. The Garante established that Facebook had obtained access without sufficiently specific consent. It did not claim to have determined that every photograph or video stored on affected devices had been examined or used.

Meta Challenges Italian Regulator's Authority

The decision rests on Article 122 of Italy's Data Protection Code, which implements the European Union's ePrivacy Directive. The provision protects information stored on personal devices, including smartphones. The Garante said access to that information requires freely given and informed consent, regardless of whether the information is transmitted elsewhere or whether the individual suffers any demonstrable harm.

Meta challenged the Italian regulator's jurisdiction, arguing that the matter should fall under the authority of Ireland's data protection regulator.

The Garante rejected the objection, finding that the ePrivacy rules involved do not provide for the one-stop-shop mechanism used in certain cross-border cases under the General Data Protection Regulation.

The dispute over jurisdiction was therefore resolved in favor of the Italian authority, which proceeded against Meta Platforms Ireland Limited over the operation of the Facebook feature in Italy.

The regulator also specified what its investigation had not examined. The proceedings did not concern the possible use of photographs or videos to train artificial intelligence systems, which Meta denies.

A separate feature introduced in 2026, allowing camera roll content to be processed in the cloud, was likewise outside the scope of the decision. The Garante said it reserved the right to examine that functionality through a separate investigation.

Meta Given 60 Days to Change Consent Settings

Under the order, Meta must obtain consent through a request specifically addressing the camera roll suggestions feature, separate from the broader permission to access the phone's photo library. The company must explain what the feature does, make clear that it involves access to material stored on the device and tell users how to disable it.

The feature must remain switched off by default, including for users who have already granted the application access to their camera rolls. If Meta fails to comply within 60 days, it cannot enable the feature for users who have not provided valid consent.

The regulator has also imposed reporting requirements. Meta must inform the Garante within 30 days of the initiatives it has undertaken and report the measures adopted within 90 days.

The size of the penalty reflects several factors identified during the investigation. The authority cited the approximately 20 million Android users affected in Italy, along with the duration of the infringement, which it said remained ongoing for users who had not updated the application and for those who had already granted the relevant system permission. The Garante also considered a previous decision against Meta in 2019 and what it described as poor cooperation during the investigation.

Changes made by Meta after the consumer organization's report were treated as mitigating circumstances. The regulator nevertheless found that those modifications had been introduced late and applied only to users who updated the application.

The €805 million penalty represents approximately 0.47% of Meta's global group turnover, according to the authority. The order requires Meta to address both the information provided to users and the settings governing the feature. Previously granted permission to access a phone's photo library will not be sufficient to keep camera roll suggestions enabled. Users must instead be given a separate explanation of the feature and an opportunity to consent to its use.

 The GRC Report is your premier destination for the latest in governance, risk, and compliance news. As your reliable source for comprehensive coverage, we ensure you stay informed and ready to navigate the dynamic landscape of GRC. Beyond being a news source, the GRC Report represents a thriving community of professionals who, like you, are dedicated to GRC excellence. Explore our insightful articles and breaking news, and actively participate in the conversation to enhance your GRC journey.

Oops! Something went wrong