New Zealand Commerce Commission Warns Businesses That AI Does Not Change Their Legal Responsibilities
Key Takeaways
- Existing Laws Apply to AI: New Zealand's Commerce Commission has clarified that the Fair Trading Act 1986 and Commerce Act 1986 continue to apply when businesses use artificial intelligence in commercial activities.
- Businesses Remain Accountable: Companies retain legal responsibility for decisions and outcomes produced through AI, regardless of whether those decisions originate with employees, algorithms, or AI systems.
- Board Oversight Is Essential: The Commission is encouraging boards and senior executives to maintain visibility over AI use and incorporate competition and consumer protection considerations into governance and risk management frameworks.
- Continuous Monitoring Is Expected: Businesses are being urged to understand where AI is deployed, how it influences decisions, and whether appropriate safeguards are in place to address potential legal risks.
- Additional Regulation Remains Possible: The guidance introduces no new statutory obligations, although the Commission acknowledges that policymakers and regulators may consider further safeguards as AI develops.
Deep Dive
New Zealand's Commerce Commission has little interest in whether a company's commercial decisions originate with an employee or an artificial intelligence system. What concerns the regulator is whether those decisions comply with the law, and whether the business responsible for them has taken sufficient care to ensure that they do.
That was the message accompanying new guidance published Wednesday, as the Commission sought to clarify the obligations of businesses increasingly relying on AI to interact with customers, conduct transactions, and compete in New Zealand markets.
Deputy Chair Anne Callinan was unequivocal about where responsibility lies.
"Whether a decision is made by a person, an algorithm, or an AI system, the business remains accountable for the outcome," she said. "Using AI does not shift that accountability and responsibility. Businesses must make sure the information they provide is accurate, their decisions comply with the law, and consumers are treated fairly."
The guidance addresses the application of two longstanding pieces of legislation, the Fair Trading Act 1986 and the Commerce Act 1986. The former protects consumers and businesses against misleading and deceptive conduct and unfair practices, while the latter prohibits anti-competitive behavior, including cartel conduct and misuse of market power. Neither ceases to apply when a business introduces AI into its operations.
The Commission is not seeking to regulate AI technology itself. Its interest lies in the consequences of its use, particularly where automated decisions or AI-generated outputs could affect consumers or competition.
The distinction leaves businesses with an immediate responsibility to understand how the technology operates within their organizations and whether its use creates risks under existing law. The Commission's guidance identifies potential areas of noncompliance and offers practical measures businesses can take to address them.
"As AI continues to evolve, policymakers and regulators will continue to consider whether additional regulatory tools or safeguards may be needed," Callinan said. "But businesses have clear obligations today, and they should not assume AI changes those responsibilities."
The possibility of further regulation remains open, but the Commission has given businesses little reason to wait for it. Callinan has also directed the regulator's message toward boards and senior executives, urging them to treat AI as a corporate governance matter rather than leaving its oversight entirely to those responsible for implementing the technology.
"Organisations need to continually monitor where and how AI is being used, how it is influencing decisions, the products and outcomes it is creating, and whether sufficient safeguards are in place," she said.
The Commission wants boards to have visibility over AI use throughout their organizations, including an understanding of the commercial decisions it influences and the safeguards intended to prevent unlawful outcomes. Competition and consumer protection considerations, Callinan said, should form part of existing AI governance and risk management frameworks.
That expectation carries particular significance for businesses adopting AI across multiple functions. A system introduced to support one commercial activity may influence decisions or produce outputs that carry legal consequences elsewhere in the organization. The Commission is therefore encouraging businesses to examine not merely where AI has been deployed, but what it is doing and whether the resulting conduct meets their obligations.
"Boards should have visibility of how AI is being used across their organisation and ensure competition and consumer protection considerations are built into their AI governance and risk management frameworks," Callinan said.
The guidance does not establish new statutory duties or prescribe a particular governance model. Instead, it asks businesses to apply existing legal requirements to the ways they are already using AI, identify the risks associated with those activities, and introduce appropriate safeguards before problems arise.
The Commission will discuss the guidance at a free webinar with the AI Forum on November 24.
The GRC Report is your premier destination for the latest in governance, risk, and compliance news. As your reliable source for comprehensive coverage, we ensure you stay informed and ready to navigate the dynamic landscape of GRC. Beyond being a news source, the GRC Report represents a thriving community of professionals who, like you, are dedicated to GRC excellence. Explore our insightful articles and breaking news, and actively participate in the conversation to enhance your GRC journey.



