Find the Right GRC Solution

Search and compare GRC technology built for the problems you’re trying to solve

Poland’s UOKiK Fines Electricity Contractors $3.5 Million Over Bid-Rigging, FARAD Plans Appeal

Poland’s UOKiK Fines Electricity Contractors $3.5 Million Over Bid-Rigging, FARAD Plans Appeal

By
Key Takeaways
  • 11 Tenders Affected: UOKiK found that electricity infrastructure contractors coordinated their conduct in 11 tenders organized by PGE Dystrybucja.
  • Companies Decided Who Would Win: According to the authority, participants agreed which bidder would secure particular contracts and when competitors would stop lowering their prices.
  • Phone Calls Exposed the Arrangements: UOKiK cited conversations in which bidders discussed withdrawing from auctions and allowing competitors to win. FARAD's owner has clarified that he was not responsible for the statements quoted in the article.
  • More Than $3.5 Million in Fines: UOKiK imposed penalties totaling more than $3.5 million (PLN 13.5 million), with ZPUE receiving the largest individual fine.
  • FARAD Challenges Decision: FARAD's owner disputes UOKiK's findings and intends to appeal. He has also raised concerns about the calculation of the company's fine and cited an earlier court ruling criticizing delays in the proceedings.
Deep Dive

“Next time I call, you’ll be the ones to back down.”

The remark appears among the telephone conversations cited by Poland's competition authority in its investigation into alleged bid-rigging among electricity infrastructure contractors. According to the Office of Competition and Consumer Protection, or UOKiK, the conversations helped establish how companies decided who would win particular tenders and when their competitors would stop bidding.

UOKiK imposed more than $3.5 million (PLN 13.5 million) in fines after finding that contractors coordinated their behavior in 11 tenders organized by electricity distributor PGE Dystrybucja. The contracts covered the construction and modernization of electricity grid infrastructure, including switching and disconnection points.

The mechanism was straightforward. PGE Dystrybucja was supposed to select the best offer through electronic auctions. UOKiK found that some bidders had already settled the important question before those auctions ran their course, deciding which company was supposed to win.

“The undertakings were aware that they were acting unlawfully,” UOKiK President Tomasz Chróstny said. He said the companies repeatedly contacted one another by phone to divide successive tenders and, no later than the day of an electronic auction, knew which participant was expected to take the contract.

Those calls became important evidence in the case. One of the agreements concerned the modernization of the Garwolin–Żelechów 15 kV medium-voltage electricity grid. UOKiK identified EnergoTech of Lublin, Przedsiębiorstwo Techniczno-Usługowe Elektra of Lublin and Przedsiębiorstwo Handlowo-Usługowe Kurpiewski of Łomża as participants.

The companies agreed that PHU Kurpiewski would take the contract, according to UOKiK. The consortium of PTU Elektra and EnergoTech was supposed to stay out of the way. In practice, that meant not lowering its price.

There was an expectation that the favor would eventually be returned. The conversations cited by the authority included assurances that “the bread would be returned” and that one participant would “not get in the way in the other case.” Then came the more explicit expectation that “next time I call, you’ll be the ones to back down.”

UOKiK imposed approximately $886,424 (PLN 3,419,938.78) in penalties over that agreement. EnergoTech was fined approximately $153,094 (PLN 590,656.16), PTU Elektra approximately $193,738 (PLN 747,467.75) and PHU Kurpiewski approximately $539,592 (PLN 2,081,814.87).

The second agreement was larger. It concerned tenders for radio-controlled switching points and involved EnergoTech, ZPUE of Włoszczowa, PTU Elektra, Ekto of Zaścianki, Elmo of Żelków-Kolonia and Przedsiębiorstwo Wielobranżowe FARAD of Józefów.

Again, the telephone conversations featured prominently in UOKiK's findings. At one point, a company asked a competitor “not to go for ice cream tomorrow.” UOKiK said the message was understood to mean that the competitor should not submit further bids in the auction. The same participant explained that “the idea was that we would, you know, be the ones to do it.”

The other companies could still bid. Under the arrangement described by UOKiK, however, they were not supposed to compete hard enough to upset the planned result. The authority found that participants would at most create the appearance of price competition without threatening ZPUE's leading position.

The conversations also suggested that the companies were thinking beyond individual auctions. In another case examined by UOKiK, participants suggested raising their prices “by five each” compared with an earlier tender because they considered the previous bids too low against the contracting authority's budget. They spoke approvingly of bids coming from companies belonging to the “old set-up.” A company allocated one contract could also agree to stay away from later contracts.

Following publication of this article, FARAD owner Zbigniew Kwiatosz contacted GRC Report to clarify that none of the quoted statements concerning “ice cream,” “bread,” the “old set-up” or withdrawing from subsequent auctions had been made by him. The original article did not attribute those remarks to Kwiatosz, but he said he wanted to make the distinction clear because FARAD was identified among the companies involved in the second arrangement.

That second set of arrangements brought approximately $2.64 million (PLN 10,176,777.57) in penalties. ZPUE received the largest fine, approximately $1.98 million (PLN 7,642,588.80). EnergoTech was fined approximately $120,026 (PLN 463,074.43), PTU Elektra approximately $119,343 (PLN 460,440.13), Ekto approximately $78,369 (PLN 302,358.71), Elmo approximately $174,318 (PLN 672,517.44) and FARAD approximately $182,225 (PLN 703,049.80).

FARAD Disputes Findings and Questions Fine Calculation

Kwiatosz told GRC Report that FARAD disagrees with UOKiK's findings and intends to challenge the decision in court. He also drew attention to an earlier judgment concerning the conduct of the same antitrust proceedings.

According to the court judgment described and supplied by Kwiatosz, the Voivodeship Administrative Court in Warsaw ruled on July 31, 2026, in case V SAB/Wa 36/26 that UOKiK had conducted the proceedings in a protracted manner amounting to a gross violation of law.

Kwiatosz said the court ordered UOKiK to conclude the proceedings within one month of receiving the final judgment and case files and awarded him PLN 5,000, payable by the authority.

He also provided an account of a subsequent freedom-of-information response from UOKiK, dated September 29, 2026. According to Kwiatosz, the authority stated that no other administrative court judgment since January 27, 2020, had found that the UOKiK president conducted proceedings in a protracted manner constituting a gross violation of law.

Kwiatosz argues that the length of the proceedings is particularly consequential because the underlying events date primarily to 2017. He has raised concerns about the difficulty of reconstructing events and mounting a defense nearly a decade later.

He has also questioned the calculation of FARAD's penalty.

An English translation of pages 75–76 of UOKiK Decision DOK-6/2026, provided in correspondence with GRC Report, shows that the authority calculated an intermediate fine of PLN 117,174.97 for FARAD after accounting for aggravating circumstances. The amount included a 20% increase applied to all six companies in the second arrangement because UOKiK considered their conduct intentional.

In paragraph 256, the authority subsequently increased FARAD's penalty to PLN 703,049.80, approximately six times the intermediate amount.

The decision explains that UOKiK considered the previously calculated penalties insufficient to achieve their intended purposes. It cites proportionality, the potential benefits of the arrangements and the need for an effective deterrent. The authority also made upward and downward adjustments to penalties imposed on other companies.

Kwiatosz argues that the paragraph does not adequately explain why FARAD, specifically, warranted a sixfold increase. He has questioned whether the adjustment could have been retaliatory in light of his earlier successful challenge to UOKiK's handling of the proceedings.

That suggestion remains an allegation by Kwiatosz. The chronology and fine calculation, on their own, do not establish that UOKiK acted in retaliation, and the material provided does not demonstrate such a motive. Paragraph 256 gives the authority's general reasons for adjusting the penalties but does not separately explain the precise sixfold increase applied to FARAD.

Kwiatosz has called for UOKiK to provide a more detailed explanation of the adjustment.

The decision remains subject to judicial challenge, and FARAD's objections to the findings and penalty have not been resolved by a court.

Competition Findings Remain Subject to Appeal

The dispute over FARAD's penalty arises from a broader enforcement action in which UOKiK concluded that contractors had interfered with the competitive process for electricity infrastructure contracts.

Electronic auctions depend on bidders continuing to compete independently. According to UOKiK's findings, participants in these tenders coordinated their bidding behavior, sometimes agreeing in advance which company would win and which competitors would refrain from further price reductions.

The authority's findings and the penalties it imposed remain non-final. The companies retain the right to challenge the decision before a court.

Editor's Note — October 15, 2026: This article, originally published September 30, 2026, has been updated following correspondence from Zbigniew Kwiatosz, owner of FARAD, one of the companies named in UOKiK's decision. The update clarifies that Kwiatosz was not the speaker of the telephone quotations reproduced in the article, according to his statement, and adds FARAD's disagreement with the decision and stated intention to appeal. It also reports Kwiatosz's account of a July 31, 2026, administrative court judgment concerning delays in the proceedings, his account of a subsequent UOKiK information response, and his objections to the calculation of FARAD's fine. The article now explains the intermediate penalty calculation and subsequent adjustment described in paragraph 256 of Decision DOK-6/2026. FARAD's suggestion of possible retaliation is identified as an allegation, not an established finding. The fine attributed to Elmo in the second arrangement has also been corrected from PLN 605,265.70 to PLN 672,517.44, consistent with the decision excerpt provided to GRC Report.

The GRC Report is your premier destination for the latest in governance, risk, and compliance news. As your reliable source for comprehensive coverage, we ensure you stay informed and ready to navigate the dynamic landscape of GRC. Beyond being a news source, the GRC Report represents a thriving community of professionals who, like you, are dedicated to GRC excellence. Explore our insightful articles and breaking news, and actively participate in the conversation to enhance your GRC journey.

Oops! Something went wrong