SEC Staff Issues Net Capital Relief for eToro USA Zero Cash Balance Brokerage Model

Key Takeaways
- The SEC Division of Trading and Markets has received a no-action request from eToro USA Securities Inc.
- concerning a "zero cash balance" brokerage model, in which customer cash stays at a bank or FinCEN-registered money services business (MSB) rather than at the broker-dealer.
- The firm asks to operate as an introducing broker-dealer with minimum net capital of the greater of USD $5,000 or the amount required under Rule 15c3-1(a)(1).
- The structure could shape how firms treat customer cash, net capital, and SIPA disclosures, so compliance teams should review it closely.
Deep Dive
The SEC Division of Trading and Markets has received a no-action request from eToro USA Securities Inc. concerning a "zero cash balance" brokerage model, in which customer cash stays at a bank or FinCEN-registered money services business (MSB) rather than at the broker-dealer. The firm asks to operate as an introducing broker-dealer with minimum net capital of the greater of USD $5,000 or the amount required under Rule 15c3-1(a)(1). The structure could shape how firms treat customer cash, net capital, and SIPA disclosures, so compliance teams should review it closely.
Customers fund purchases by instructing an MSB or bank (the "External Cash Account") to transfer cash to the Carrying Firm. Sale proceeds are promptly swept back to the External Cash Account under standing customer authorization. The introducing firm represents that it does not receive or hold customer funds or securities, does not carry customer accounts, and does not engage in the activities in Rule 15c3-1(a)(2)(i) through (v). It clears on a fully disclosed basis, and the Carrying Firm maintains the books and records under Rules 17a-3 and 17a-4. The requested assurance covers Exchange Act Section 15(c)(3) and Rule 15c3-1(a). The firm's letter cites the (a)(2)(vi) minimum of USD $5,000. The Division's summary frames the minimum as the greater of USD $5,000 or the (a)(1) requirement.
Several conditions are embedded in the representations and would likely be treated as limits on any relief. Customer agreements must clearly disclose that funds in the External Cash Account are not SIPC-protected, because they are not held as "customer" claims under SIPA. Disclosures must also appear prominently on the platform. External Cash Account funds must not be commingled with the MSB's proprietary funds. The firm must periodically verify the MSB's licensure and registration. Free credit balances must be promptly remitted. No specific effective date or deadline is stated.
Recommended actions: Broker-dealers considering similar models should benchmark them against these representations and consider whether to seek their own relief. Carrying firms should assess how this flow affects Rule 15c3-3 customer reserve calculations, free credit treatment, and settlement timing, including T+1 funding gaps. Firms should review third-party oversight of MSBs and banks, including licensing checks, safeguarding of funds, and AML/BSA responsibilities. Disclosure and marketing teams should check for any risk that customers misunderstand SIPC coverage, and should treat that risk as a significant conduct concern.
Risk implications: The structure lowers the introducing firm's capital burden and shifts cash-custody risk to non-broker-dealer entities outside SIPA protection. This raises investor protection, counterparty, and operational risks. Examiners may focus on disclosure quality, the promptness of cash sweeps, and reliance on MSB safeguards. Precedent risk exists if other firms adopt the model without equivalent controls.

