Find the Right GRC Solution

Search and compare GRC technology built for the problems you’re trying to solve

UK Financial Reporting Council Issues Guidance on Auditor Independence When Using AI

UK Financial Reporting Council Issues Guidance on Auditor Independence When Using AI

By
🔒
Cancel anytime
Full archive access
Custom alerts
Key Takeaways
  • FRC Publishes New Guidance: The UK's Financial Reporting Council issued guidance on November 16 addressing how auditors should maintain integrity, objectivity and independence when using AI and other technologies to generate insights for audited entities.
  • Independence Risks Identified: Communicating technology-derived insights can create ethical threats, particularly when the work used to obtain those findings falls outside the financial statement audit.
  • Technology Access Addressed: The guidance covers both the communication of findings to management or those charged with governance and arrangements allowing audited entities to obtain insights directly through technology.
  • Existing Ethical Standards Apply: Developed in response to requests from auditors, the guidance supports the application of the FRC's Ethical Standard without establishing a general prohibition on sharing technology-generated insights.
  • Audit Quality Remains a Priority: The FRC recognizes that AI and other technologies can improve audit quality, including by identifying risks of material misstatement and opportunities to strengthen internal controls.
Deep Dive

The UK's Financial Reporting Council (FRC) has issued guidance clarifying how auditors should apply professional ethics requirements when using artificial intelligence and other technologies to produce information that may be useful to the companies they audit.

Published November 16, the guidance addresses questions raised by audit firms about the circumstances in which technology-generated insights can be shared with company management or those charged with governance without compromising the auditor's independence.

The issue has become more pressing as audit firms adopt technologies capable of examining financial information in greater detail. The FRC acknowledges that these tools can improve audit quality by helping auditors identify risks of material misstatement and weaknesses in internal controls. They can also produce findings that companies may find useful beyond the immediate purposes of the financial statement audit. It is the treatment of those additional findings that has prompted the regulator's intervention.

Auditors are required to maintain their integrity, objectivity and independence when carrying out statutory audits. According to the FRC, communicating insights obtained through technology can create threats to those obligations in certain circumstances, particularly when the work undertaken to produce the information falls outside the financial statement audit.

The guidance considers how auditors should approach such communications and whether it is appropriate to provide audited companies with access to technology that enables management or those charged with governance to obtain insights directly.

The latter raises a related ethical question. Rather than receiving findings prepared and communicated by an auditor, a company may be given the means to obtain information through technology made available by its audit firm. The FRC has included both arrangements within the scope of its guidance.

The regulator developed the document after receiving requests from auditors seeking assistance with the application of its Ethical Standard to particular circumstances, many involving technology. Its purpose is to clarify how existing ethical requirements should be considered when firms contemplate providing additional information to their audit clients.

The FRC has identified two objectives. It wants to reduce the risk of auditors providing insights that undermine their ability to discharge their statutory responsibilities. It also wants firms to have sufficient confidence in their understanding of the ethical requirements to communicate findings where doing so does not compromise their integrity, objectivity or independence.

Mark Babington, the FRC's executive director of regulatory standards, said the increasing use of AI offered opportunities to improve audit work but could not come at the expense of auditor independence.

"The use of AI by auditors can enhance the quality of audit work done and the insights provided to audited entities," Babington said. "However, auditor independence is and must remain at the heart of audits providing value and serving the public interest."

The guidance does not establish a general prohibition on communicating findings obtained through AI or other technology. The FRC's approach is to help auditors determine how the Ethical Standard applies to the circumstances in which information is produced and provided.

That distinction is important for firms seeking to make greater use of technology in their audit work. An analysis undertaken for audit purposes may reveal matters that management would benefit from understanding. Other insights may result from work that goes beyond the financial statement audit, introducing ethical considerations that require separate attention.

The regulator's guidance is intended to help firms recognize those differences before communicating findings or providing access to the technology through which they are obtained.

The central consideration remains whether the information they provide is consistent with their responsibilities as independent auditors. The FRC is encouraging the appropriate use of technology, while making clear that its benefits must be assessed alongside the professional obligations governing the audit relationship.

 The GRC Report is your premier destination for the latest in governance, risk, and compliance news. As your reliable source for comprehensive coverage, we ensure you stay informed and ready to navigate the dynamic landscape of GRC. Beyond being a news source, the GRC Report represents a thriving community of professionals who, like you, are dedicated to GRC excellence. Explore our insightful articles and breaking news, and actively participate in the conversation to enhance your GRC journey.

Oops! Something went wrong