Find the Right GRC Solution

Search and compare GRC technology built for the problems you’re trying to solve

ASIC Sues Lead Generator Clark Family Over Alleged Misleading Comparison Website Claims

ASIC Sues Lead Generator Clark Family Over Alleged Misleading Comparison Website Claims

By
Regulatory data powered by Corlytics
ASIC has commenced Federal Court proceedings against Clark Family Pty Ltd, alleging that up to 70 websites claimed to compare loan and insurance products and t…
🔒
Cancel anytime
Full archive access
Custom alerts
Key Takeaways
  • ASIC has commenced Federal Court proceedings against Clark Family Pty Ltd, alleging that up to 70 websites claimed to compare loan and insurance products and tailor recommendations when consumer enquiries were actually sold to the highest bidding broker.
  • The case shows that ASIC is scrutinizing lead generation and comparison models, and that representations about comparison or tailoring must match the service actually provided.
  • Compliance teams at lenders, insurers, brokers, and marketing partners should review their exposure.
Deep Dive

ASIC has commenced Federal Court proceedings against Clark Family Pty Ltd, alleging that up to 70 websites claimed to compare loan and insurance products and tailor recommendations when consumer enquiries were actually sold to the highest bidding broker. The case shows that ASIC is scrutinizing lead generation and comparison models, and that representations about comparison or tailoring must match the service actually provided. Compliance teams at lenders, insurers, brokers, and marketing partners should review their exposure.

The legal basis is sections 12DB and 12DF of the ASIC Act 2001, which cover false or misleading representations about financial services and misleading conduct relating to financial services. ASIC is seeking declarations, pecuniary penalties, an adverse publicity order, and injunctive relief. No penalty amount has been specified. The alleged conduct period of roughly six years suggests ASIC is willing to pursue long-running practices, and the relief sought includes reputational consequences beyond financial penalties. ASIC Chair Sarah Court emphasized that claims about comparing products or identifying suitable options must accurately reflect the service provided.

For regulated firms, the implications extend beyond the defendant. Lenders, insurers, and brokers that buy leads from third-party generators may face scrutiny over how those leads were sourced and how consumers were told their information would be used. Firms should consider whether their distribution arrangements could expose them to accessorial liability or to reputational and conduct risk. Firms operating their own comparison tools should confirm that the number of providers covered, any commercial relationships, and any ranking or bidding mechanics are accurately disclosed.

Recommended actions:
- Inventory all lead generation, referral, and comparison partnerships, and review the claims made on their websites and in advertising.
- Strengthen due diligence and contractual protections with lead generators, including accuracy warranties, audit rights, marketing pre-approval, and termination rights.
- Review your own marketing language for terms such as "compare," "best," "tailored," or "matched to your needs," and substantiate each claim.
- Ensure consumer-facing disclosures explain how enquiries are handled, including if data is sold or shared, and whether payment influences who contacts the consumer.
- Update monitoring, complaints analysis, and training for marketing and distribution teams, and brief senior management and boards on the enforcement trend.

Source: Australian Securities and Investments Commission

Oops! Something went wrong