Find the Right GRC Solution

Search and compare GRC technology built for the problems you’re trying to solve

Bank of England Paper Finds Dealer-Specific Pricing Drives Wide Dispersion in Synthetic Dollar Fundi

Bank of England Paper Finds Dealer-Specific Pricing Drives Wide Dispersion in Synthetic Dollar Fundi

By
Regulatory data powered by Corlytics
A Bank of England Staff Working Paper finds that FX forward prices for synthetic dollar funding vary by dealer, with a standard deviation of about 4 basis poin…
🔒
Cancel anytime
Full archive access
Custom alerts
Key Takeaways
  • A Bank of England Staff Working Paper finds that FX forward prices for synthetic dollar funding vary by dealer, with a standard deviation of about 4 basis points per year.
  • Dealers also charge more for buying dollars forward than for selling them, and the gap reaches 11.8 basis points at maturities under one month.
  • Compliance teams should note that the pricing differences reflect dealer clientele and pricing power more than funding costs, which raises best execution, conduct, and market fairness questions.
Deep Dive

A Bank of England Staff Working Paper finds that FX forward prices for synthetic dollar funding vary by dealer, with a standard deviation of about 4 basis points per year. Dealers also charge more for buying dollars forward than for selling them, and the gap reaches 11.8 basis points at maturities under one month. Compliance teams should note that the pricing differences reflect dealer clientele and pricing power more than funding costs, which raises best execution, conduct, and market fairness questions.

The main findings are as follows:
- Dealer-specific prices have a standard deviation of about 4 basis points per year, and the dispersion appears both across dealers at a point in time and over time for a given dealer.
- Dealers charge 2.5 basis points more to buy dollars forward than to sell them. The gap widens to 11.8 basis points at maturities under one month.
- The asymmetry persists after controlling for client-dealer relationships and trade characteristics.
- Differences in dealer funding costs explain little of the dispersion. The authors attribute it mainly to dealer clientele and pricing power.

For compliance teams, the findings are relevant to best execution, fair treatment of clients, and pricing transparency in FX swaps and forwards. This applies to firms acting as dealers and to firms that use dealers, such as asset managers, corporate treasuries, and pension funds. If pricing differences reflect market power and not cost, regulators may ask whether clients are comparing quotes and whether execution policies are applied in practice. Dealer-side teams may face questions about pricing governance and about whether pricing differs systematically by client segment. Buy-side teams may face questions about how they select counterparties and document the process. Because the effect is larger at short maturities, short-dated hedging and liquidity management activity may be most exposed.

Recommended actions:
- Review best execution and transaction cost analysis (TCA) frameworks for FX forwards and swaps. Confirm that they capture dealer-level price dispersion and direction-specific (buy versus sell) cost differences.
- Where multi-dealer quoting is feasible, confirm that it is used and documented, especially for short-dated trades.
- Dealer-side firms should assess whether pricing governance, spread-setting, and client tiering practices are defensible and consistently applied.
- Monitor Bank of England and other regulatory commentary on FX market structure, and brief senior management and relevant committees on the findings.

Overall impact is low in the near term and moderate in the longer term. The research gives supervisors and policymakers evidence that could shape future work on FX market conduct and transparency. It also adds to the evidence base on dollar funding market functioning. Firms should treat it as an early indicator and not as a basis for immediate remediation.

Source: Bank of England

Oops! Something went wrong