Canada's Competition Bureau Unveils New Guidelines to Combat Greenwashing

Key Takeaways

• New Guidelines for Environmental Claims: The Competition Bureau's updated guidelines provide businesses with clear instructions on how to avoid greenwashing by substantiating environmental claims with proper evidence and internationally recognized methodologies.
• Focus on Future Claims: Environmental claims about future goals, like net-zero emissions, must be supported by a realistic, verifiable plan with interim targets and substantiated through proper testing and third-party verification.
• Penalties for Non-Compliance: Businesses making false or misleading environmental claims could face fines up to $10 million or 3% of annual revenues, with penalties increasing for repeat offenders.
• Transparency and Accountability: The guidelines stress that businesses must ensure their claims are not misleading, clear, and specific, avoiding exaggeration and ensuring that they are substantiated with scientific or third-party verification.
• Impact on Industry: Some businesses, like RBC, have already scaled back their environmental claims following these regulatory changes, highlighting the impact of the new rules on corporate sustainability strategies.

Deep Dive

Canada’s Competition Bureau has released its final guidelines aimed at curbing greenwashing, a growing concern in the marketing world. The new framework provides businesses with clear instructions on how to make legitimate environmental claims about their products and operations under the country’s amended Competition Act. This new set of rules comes on the heels of Canada’s broader push to address deceptive marketing practices, particularly those related to environmental sustainability.

The guidelines outline how businesses can avoid making misleading environmental claims by requiring that any claim regarding a product’s environmental benefits, whether it be related to sustainability, net-zero goals, or climate impacts, must be based on solid evidence. In particular, the Bureau emphasizes the necessity of a concrete, realistic, and verifiable plan for claims about the future, such as net-zero commitments. Claims lacking proper substantiation will be scrutinized, with the Bureau noting that "claims about the future can be considered greenwashing if they represent little more than wishful thinking."

Steps for Compliance:

• Substantiation of Claims: Environmental claims, especially those about future goals like reaching net-zero emissions, must be backed by internationally recognized methodologies and must come with a clear action plan that includes interim targets.
• Testing and Verification: Businesses must conduct actual testing to substantiate claims about product performance or environmental benefits. This is a shift from relying on anecdotal evidence or similar product studies.
• Third-Party Verification: For certain claims, especially those related to a company’s business practices or overall environmental impact, third-party verification may be necessary to ensure that the claims meet internationally accepted standards.

Legal Penalties and Enforcement

The guidelines also stress that businesses found to be making false or misleading environmental claims could face significant penalties. Under the amended Competition Act, companies could be fined as much as the greater of $10 million, $15 million for subsequent violations, or up to 3% of their annual revenues, with fines potentially tripling the financial benefits derived from deceptive practices. The new laws were introduced in response to growing concerns over "greenwashing," a practice where businesses exaggerate or misrepresent their environmental sustainability efforts.

Since the passage of the new rules, some businesses have begun adjusting their sustainability claims. For instance, the Royal Bank of Canada (RBC) recently retracted its commitment to mobilize $500 billion in sustainable finance, citing the regulatory changes. The Competition Bureau held consultations to refine these guidelines, acknowledging requests from companies for more clarity on what environmental claims are acceptable.

The Bureau provided an example of a business that claimed to be on track to reach net-zero emissions by 2050 without a clear plan or methodology in place. Such a claim would be deemed non-compliant with the new regulations unless substantiated by proper evidence and a feasible, internationally recognized approach.

Principles for Compliance

To help businesses navigate the new regulations, the Competition Bureau laid out several key principles for ensuring that environmental claims are truthful and accurately represented:

1. Truthfulness: Claims should be truthful in both their literal meaning and their general impression.
2. Adequate Testing: Environmental claims about products must be substantiated by proper testing, not simply anecdotal evidence or assumptions.
3. Specific Comparisons: When making comparative environmental claims, businesses must be clear about what is being compared.
4. Avoiding Exaggeration: Companies must avoid overstating environmental claims, ensuring they are specific and not misleading.
5. Clarity and Specificity: Environmental claims must avoid vagueness and be clear in their meaning.
6. Support for Future Claims: Claims about future goals, such as net-zero emissions, must be backed by solid plans, clear steps, and achievable targets.

The Bureau concluded by emphasizing the importance of transparency in environmental claims, stating that such claims are influential in shaping consumer behavior. Businesses that follow these new guidelines will not only ensure legal compliance but will also improve consumer trust by providing substantiated, verifiable claims.

As the global push for sustainability continues to grow, Canada’s efforts to regulate greenwashing will likely set a precedent for other nations grappling with similar challenges. Businesses are encouraged to review these new guidelines carefully to ensure that their environmental claims align with the expectations set out in the Competition Act.

The GRC Report is your premier destination for the latest in governance, risk, and compliance news. As your reliable source for comprehensive coverage, we ensure you stay informed and ready to navigate the dynamic landscape of GRC. Beyond being a news source, the GRC Report represents a thriving community of professionals who, like you, are dedicated to GRC excellence. Explore our insightful articles and breaking news, and actively participate in the conversation to enhance your GRC journey.