US Banking Regulators Extend Comment Period on Proposed Third-Party Risk Management Guidance
Key Takeaways
- Comment Deadline Extended: The FDIC, Federal Reserve, NCUA, and OCC extended the public comment period on proposed third-party risk management guidance from November 16 to December 16, 2026.
- Greater Emphasis on Risk-Based Oversight: The proposed guidance would encourage financial institutions to tailor due diligence, monitoring, and other oversight practices to the risks associated with individual third-party relationships.
- Existing Guidance to Be Replaced: The federal banking agencies intend to rescind existing third-party risk management guidance upon finalization, while the NCUA also plans to review related materials for possible updates.
- Supervisory Responsibilities Remain: The proposed guidance would be non-binding, but banks and credit unions would remain responsible for compliance with applicable laws and regulations and for managing risks arising from outsourced activities.
- Community Bank Consultation Extended: The Federal Reserve separately extended the comment period for its proposed third-party risk management guide for traditional community banks until December 16.
Deep Dive
Federal banking regulators have given financial institutions another 30 days to comment on a proposal that could change how banks and credit unions assess the risks of doing business with outside providers. The extension, announced Friday, November 13, moves the deadline to December 16 and leaves open a debate over whether existing supervisory guidance has encouraged too much attention to procedure and too little to the risks themselves.
The Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), Federal Reserve Board, National Credit Union Administration (NCUA), and Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) are seeking to replace existing third-party risk management guidance with a framework that gives institutions greater discretion over how they supervise individual relationships.
The proposal reflects concerns the agencies have developed through supervisory examinations and feedback from financial institutions. Regulators say existing guidance, particularly the interagency framework adopted in 2023, has sometimes been interpreted as a collection of prescribed practices rather than principles that institutions can adapt to their circumstances.
For banks and credit unions, the distinction has practical consequences. A provider responsible for essential banking operations may expose an institution to substantial financial losses or service disruptions if something goes wrong. A company performing routine administrative work may present far less risk. The agencies want institutions to make those distinctions when deciding where to concentrate their oversight resources.
In explaining the proposed revisions, regulators acknowledged that financial institutions had sometimes struggled to determine which elements of the 2023 guidance applied to particular relationships. Detailed examples intended to illustrate sound practices could instead suggest that similar procedures were appropriate for providers with markedly different responsibilities.
The agencies also questioned the existing guidance's emphasis on activities classified as critical. That approach, they said, could encourage heightened oversight without sufficient consideration of the likelihood or potential severity of harm arising from a particular relationship.
The proposed replacement would place risk identification and assessment at the center of third-party oversight. Financial institutions would be encouraged to evaluate individual relationships according to their size, complexity, and risk profile, as well as the services being provided and the consequences of a potential failure.
Those assessments would inform decisions about due diligence, contract negotiations, ongoing monitoring, and other oversight measures. Institutions could reasonably devote greater attention to providers whose failure might interrupt essential operations, cause material financial harm, or result in violations of applicable laws and regulations.
The proposal also recognizes that similar services can present different risks depending on how an institution uses them. A core processing provider supporting a limited portion of a bank's business, for example, may warrant a different assessment from one responsible for most of its operations.
Regulators have sought to address another difficulty encountered by financial institutions: obtaining information and negotiating protections from third parties that may have considerably greater bargaining power.
Under the proposed guidance, an institution could determine that a relationship remains appropriate even when a provider declines to furnish certain information or agree to particular contractual terms. Such decisions would depend on the risks involved, the availability of other safeguards, and whether the remaining exposure falls within the institution's risk appetite and tolerances.
The agencies have made clear that effective third-party risk management does not require eliminating every possible risk. They have also expressed concern that overly rigid interpretations of existing guidance may discourage banks from working with newer financial technology companies, including providers offering services that could improve an institution's operations or competitiveness.
Greater flexibility would not diminish a financial institution's underlying responsibilities. Banks and credit unions would remain accountable for complying with applicable laws and regulations and operating in a safe and sound manner, including when services are performed by outside providers or subcontractors.
The proposed guidance would also remain non-binding. The agencies have stated that departures from its recommendations would not independently justify supervisory action. Examiners would instead consider an institution's actual circumstances, including whether inadequate third-party risk management had contributed to violations of law, unsafe or unsound practices, or other material risks.
If finalized, the FDIC, Federal Reserve, and OCC intend to rescind existing third-party risk management guidance and replace it with the revised framework. The NCUA also plans to withdraw its current guidance and review related materials to determine whether additional changes are warranted.
The Federal Reserve separately announced on November 13 that it was extending the comment period for its proposed third-party risk management guide for traditional community banks under its supervision. Comments on that proposal will also be accepted through December 16.
The separate consultation addresses institutions whose reliance on outside providers can be substantial despite their comparatively limited resources. Community banks frequently depend on third parties for technology and operational capabilities that would be difficult or costly to maintain internally, a consideration acknowledged in the broader interagency proposal.
Neither proposal has been finalized, and the agencies have not announced when they expect to complete their reviews. The eventual guidance could affect how financial institutions document risk assessments, allocate oversight resources, and explain their decisions to examiners. It would also leave institutions responsible for determining when a provider's shortcomings can be managed and when the risks of maintaining the relationship have become unacceptable.
The GRC Report is your premier destination for the latest in governance, risk, and compliance news. As your reliable source for comprehensive coverage, we ensure you stay informed and ready to navigate the dynamic landscape of GRC. Beyond being a news source, the GRC Report represents a thriving community of professionals who, like you, are dedicated to GRC excellence. Explore our insightful articles and breaking news, and actively participate in the conversation to enhance your GRC journey.



